Spirited Discussions
A Lunch Community about Alcoholic Beverages.
Islay Scottish Whisky

Scottish whiskey from the Islay procing region of Scotland.

< read all 3 reviews

Certainly the best of Islay single malts

  • Aug 20, 2010

Lagavulin™ is my favorite single malt scotch!!!  I came to this much sought-after single malt through many years of drinking blended scotch whiskeys like Johnnie Walker Black.  However, I warn you, one has to work their way up to this very bold smoky taste.  Among single malt scotch aficionados, Lagavulin™ is the “gold standard” of single malts with its massive peat-smoke flavor that's typical of southern Islay - but also offering a dryness that turns it into a truly interesting drink.  It became my favorite because I usually smoke cigars when I am drinking scotch.  I have found that very few single malts can be tasted through cigar smoke on the palate; certainly none of the “Highland” scotches can stand up to a cigar!  Lagavulin™ is most often described as “a dry peat smoke that fills the palate with a gentle but strong sweetness, followed by sea and salt with touches of wood.”   Most important, a single malt aficionado drinks single malt scotch whiskey with only 3 to 4 drops of water per shot.  No ice or mixers!

How does Lagavulin™ come by its unique flavor?  According to their web site:  “Miles and miles of peat bog in the west of the island provide the raw material whose influence so characterises the south eastern Islay malts, of which Lagavulin™ is perhaps best known. Lagavulin’s™ richly peaty process water runs down the brown burn to the distillery from the Solan Lochs in the hills above the distillery. Though it shares a coastline with two neighbouring distilleries, former owner Peter Mackie took pains to ensure that Lagavulin shares its water with no-one. Rights over the water course and the surrounding land were hotly contested in his day; his persistence secured Lagavulin's legacy.”

“The barley used to distil Lagavulin™ is malted at nearby Port Ellen and has a strong peat aroma - it has perhaps twenty times as much exposure to peat smoke as a typical Speyside, Cragganmore. Fermentation of the barley is a slow process, too. Between 55 and 75 hours are taken for the full peat-rich flavour of the locally-malted barley to come through. The four stills at Lagavulin, two of them pear-shaped in the style inherited from Malt Mill, take this peaty wort and give it all the time and care it deserves. Following the original practice, Lagavulin™ receives the slowest distillation of any Islay malt - around five hours for the first distillation and more than nine hours for the second is the norm. This long distillation is often said to give Lagavulin™ the characteristic roundness and soft, mellow edges that devotees rightly prize.”

“There's nothing rushed about Islay, nor is there about Lagavulin™; before being bottled, the malt spends sixteen unhurried years breathing the sea-salt air of Islay, mainly in refill European oak casks kept in traditional white-painted warehouses by the sea shore. Long fermentation, long distillation and long maturation together ensure that Lagavulin develops all of its long, rich, peaty character. It’s is a spirit that likes to take its time. The definitive Islay malt demands nothing less.”
I suggest that if you are serious about trying single malt scotches, you do it by tasting “THE SIX CLASSIC MALTS OF SCOTLAND” of United Distillers. They are particularly selected to best represent each of the malt whiskey producing regions of Scotland.  They embrace the full diversity of regional tastes and styles.

Certainly the best of Islay single malts Certainly the best of Islay single malts Certainly the best of Islay single malts Certainly the best of Islay single malts

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
August 20, 2010
A nice informative article. I really appreciate the research. Good job!
August 20, 2010
Thank you, I will be putting up a list soon on the 6 classics.
More Islay Scotch Whisky reviews
review by . November 09, 2011
Not my favorite but others in my family disagree - Laphroaig
I love scotch.  So even if its not my favorite that does not mean I do not like it.  Laphroaig from the Islay region of Scotland is not one of my favorites, but it is still one that I will gladly accept if offfered to me.  Its one of the peaty scotches.  My partner Mark loves peat.  The smokier the better for him.  He says if it smells like band aid its a great scotch.  And you can smell the peat and the iodine band aid scent in Laphroaig.   Its has beautiful …
Quick Tip by . March 10, 2010
Iodine, peat and seaweed brine. Most Islays take a little getting used to. Bruichladdies tend to be my faves!
About the reviewer
Michael Neulander ()
Ranked #2
Recently graduated with a Masters in Humanities degree from Old Dominion University reading in philosophy and history. I graduated from the Univ. of Miami in 1980 with a B.A. in Political Science; specializing … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this topic


Islay whisky is Scotch whisky made on Islay ((pronounced /ˈaɪlə/; eye-luh)or Ìle in Gaelic, the southernmost of the Inner Hebridean Islands located off the west coast of Scotland. There are eight active distilleries on the island, as of early 2008, with a ninth being made ready for production. Islay is a centre of "whisky tourism", and hosts a "Festival of Malt and Music" known as Fèis Ìle each year at the end of May, with events and tastings celebrating the cultural heritage of the island.

Styles of Whisky

The whiskies of the distilleries along the southeastern coast of the island, Laphroaig, Lagavulin, and Ardbeg, have the strong peaty character which is considered to be characteristic of the Islay malts, and is ascribed both to the water from which the whisky is made and to the peating levels of the barley. Many describe this as a “medicinal” flavour. They also possess notes of iodine, seaweed and salt. Caol Ila, on the northern side of the island, across from Jura, produces a strongly peated whisky as well.

The other distilleries on the island make whisky in a variety of styles. Bunnahabhain and Bruichladdich make much lighter whiskies which are generally lightly peated, though Bruichladdich also produces several heavily peated products. Bowmore produces a whisky which is well balanced, using a medium-strong peating level (25ppm) but also using sherry-cask maturation. The newest distillery, Kilchoman, started ...

view wiki


Spirits, Whisky, Scotch Whisky, Islay Scotch


First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
Spirited Discussions is part of the Lunch.com Network - Get this on your site
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since